Cream Bun Turns Sour: GST Humor That Sparked a Political Storm

The recent incident involving Nirmala Sitharaman, India’s Union Finance Minister, and D. Srinivasan, the owner of the renowned Annapoorna Hotel in Coimbatore, has sparked controversy and debate surrounding the Goods and Services Tax (GST) system in India.

During a meeting on September 11, 2024, Srinivasan humorously raised concerns about the complexities of the GST rates applied to food items, highlighting the inconsistencies where cream-filled buns attract an 18% tax, while plain buns are exempt. His remarks, which drew laughter from the audience, included a light-hearted comment about customers preferring to buy buns and cream separately to avoid the higher tax.

However, following the event, a video showed Srinivasan apologizing to Sitharaman, stating, “I do not belong to any political party, please excuse me,” which led to allegations that he was coerced into apologizing. This video, shared by the Tamil Nadu BJP, ignited backlash from opposition parties, including the Congress and DMK, who accused the BJP of humiliating a small business owner for merely voicing legitimate concerns.

In response to the uproar, Tamil Nadu BJP President K. Annamalai issued an apology for the unintended breach of privacy caused by the video’s release, emphasizing Srinivasan’s contributions to the state’s economy. The incident has raised questions about the treatment of small business owners in political discourse and the broader implications of the GST system on the hospitality industry.

Jargon

Annapoorna: A well-known vegetarian restaurant chain in Tamil Nadu, famous for its traditional South Indian cuisine.
Srinivasan: D. Srinivasan, the Managing Director of the Annapoorna Hotel chain in Coimbatore, who raised concerns about GST rates during a meeting with Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman.
GST: Goods and Services Tax, a comprehensive indirect tax on the supply of goods and services in India, which has faced criticism for its complexity and varying rates.
MSMEs: Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises, which are crucial to India’s economy and often face challenges related to taxation and regulation.
Cream Bun: A popular pastry item that became a focal point in the GST discussion, highlighting the absurdity of tax rates applied to similar food items.

Viewpoints 💭

‘Left’ Viewpoint

Ideological Differences

‘Right’ Viewpoint

The incident reflects the government’s arrogance and dismissive attitude towards small business owners who raise legitimate concerns.
The forced apology of Srinivasan highlights the BJP’s tendency to coerce and intimidate critics, undermining freedom of speech.
The GST system’s complexities are a burden on small businesses, and the government has been unresponsive to calls for simplification.
Opposition leaders argue that the BJP’s actions are emblematic of a broader pattern of favoring wealthy individuals over small business owners.
The incident has sparked criticism of the BJP’s governance style, which is seen as disrespectful towards Tamil Nadu’s business community and regional sentiments.

The left views the incident as a display of government arrogance and coercion, reflecting a broader pattern of dismissiveness towards small business owners, while the right sees it as an isolated incident that was mishandled but addressed appropriately by party leaders.
Left-leaning perspectives emphasize the need for a simplified GST system to alleviate the burdens on small businesses, arguing that the current complexities are indicative of the government’s failure to support MSMEs, whereas the right defends the GST structure as a necessary differentiation between value-added and raw products, with ongoing efforts to simplify it.
The left criticizes the BJP for coercing Srinivasan into apologizing and views this as an attack on freedom of speech and the dignity of small business owners, while the right maintains that the apology was voluntary and the video leak was an unintended breach of privacy for which they have taken corrective measures.
From a left-wing standpoint, the incident is framed as part of a larger issue of the government favoring wealthy individuals over small business owners, highlighting a disparity in treatment, whereas the right-wing perspective focuses on the government’s responsiveness to feedback and its commitment to addressing concerns raised by entrepreneurs.
The left views the BJP’s handling of the situation as disrespectful to Tamil Nadu’s business community and regional sentiments, while the right emphasizes the importance of moving past the incident and focusing on the positive contributions of business leaders like Srinivasan to the local economy.

Nirmala Sitharaman’s willingness to consider the concerns raised about GST demonstrates the government’s openness to feedback from entrepreneurs.
The apology video was shared inadvertently, and the BJP has taken responsibility by expelling the functionary involved and issuing public apologies.
The GST rates are determined by consensus and are necessary for differentiating between value-added and raw products.
The BJP emphasizes respect for Srinivasan’s contributions to the economy and has taken steps to address the breach of privacy.
The government’s efforts to simplify the GST system are ongoing, and the incident should not overshadow the broader progress being made.

Prominent Voices 📣

From the ‘Left’

From the ‘Right’

M K Stalin (Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu): Criticized the Finance Minister’s handling of the hotelier’s concerns, labeling it a shameful act. ¹
Mallikarjun Kharge (Congress President): Condemned the humiliation of the restaurant owner as a reflection of the BJP’s arrogance and called for a rational GST system. ² ³
Rahul Gandhi (Congress Leader): Criticized the government’s arrogance towards small business owners and called for a simplified GST regime. ² ⁴
Aaditya Thackeray (Shiv Sena (UBT) leader): Condemned the BJP’s behavior as arrogant and questioned the legitimacy of ministers who act in such a manner. ⁵ ⁶
Kanimozhi (DMK MP): Criticized the Union government for undermining Tamil self-esteem and called for respect towards Tamil people. ² ⁵

Kovai Sathiyan (AIADMK Spokesperson): Suggested that the BJP may have pressured the hotelier to apologize and warned of electoral backlash. ⁷ ⁸
Jothimani (Karur MP and Congress Leader): Condemned Sitharaman for her arrogance and called for her to apologize for insulting the Annapoorna founder. ⁹
Selvaperunthagai (State Congress President): Argued that the Finance Minister and MLA should apologize to the hotelier instead of the BJP president, threatening nationwide protests if not addressed. ¹ ¹⁰
Supriya Shrinate (Congress spokesperson): Accused the BJP of forcing Srinivasan to apologize and recording it without his knowledge, calling it a display of arrogance. ⁶
TKS Elangovan (DMK spokesperson): Stated that the hotelier expressed the people’s voice and criticized the government for pressuring him to apologize. ¹¹ ⁹

Show less

Nirmala Sitharaman (Union Finance Minister): Acknowledged the issues raised by Srinivasan regarding GST and promised to consider them in future discussions. ¹² ⁵
K Annamalai (BJP Tamil Nadu President): Apologized for the breach of privacy regarding the viral video of Srinivasan’s apology and acknowledged Srinivasan’s contributions to the business community. ¹³ ⁴
Balaji MS (Tamil Nadu BJP Social Media Cell State Convenor): Shared the apology video, reinforcing that Srinivasan is not affiliated with any political party. ¹⁴ ¹⁵
Vanathi Srinivasan (BJP MLA): Defended the Finance Minister, stating that the apology was voluntary and denying any intimidation of the restaurant owner. ² ¹
Amar Govindarajan (Netizen): Expressed disappointment over the BJP’s handling of the situation, viewing it as an embarrassing misstep. ¹⁶